What Makes Carolina BBQ Sauce Unique?
Carolina BBQ isn’t just about the meat—it’s about the sauce. The Different Types of Carolina BBQ Sauce reflect bold regional identities, unlike sweet, thick sauces from Kansas City. These Southern cuisine staples are tangy, sharp, and thin enough to soak into meat, balancing vinegar, mustard, or pepper with acidity that cuts through rich pork. Let’s explore the BBQ regions and their signature styles.
The Four Main Types of Carolina BBQ Sauces
Carolina sauces split into four culinary traditions: Eastern NC vinegar sauce, Lexington “dip,” SC mustard sauce, and Pee Dee tomato blend. Each reflects Southern cuisine pride.
Eastern North Carolina Vinegar Sauce
This is the OG Carolina sauce. Think vinegar, red pepper flakes, and not much else. It’s watery, spicy, and perfect for pulled pork.
Ingredients and Flavor Profile
Mix apple cider vinegar, crushed red pepper, salt, and black pepper. Some add a dash of sugar, but purists skip it. The result? A tangy, spicy kick that tenderizes meat.
How It’s Used
Poured over whole-hog BBQ or used as a marinade. It keeps the pork moist and adds zing without hiding the smoke flavor.
Where to Find It
Skylight Inn in Ayden, NC, or B’s BBQ in Greenville. Pack a napkin—it’s messy.
Lexington-Style “Dip” (Western North Carolina)
Lexington sauce adds ketchup or tomato paste to the vinegar base. Sweeter than Eastern style, but still tangy.
The Tomato Twist
The tomato mellows the vinegar’s bite. Recipes often include brown sugar, making it a bridge between Eastern NC and sweeter sauces.
Meat Pairings
Best with chopped pork shoulder or on a “brown” (BBQ sandwich with slaw).
Famous Lexington BBQ Joints
Lexington BBQ Restaurant or Speedy’s—order a tray with hushpuppies.
South Carolina Mustard Sauce
This bright yellow sauce shocks outsiders. Mustard? In BBQ? Trust South Carolinians—it works.
History of Mustard in SC BBQ
German settlers brought mustard in the 1700s. Now, it’s a staple, blending mustard, vinegar, honey, and spices.
Recipe Breakdown
Combine yellow mustard, apple cider vinegar, honey, and Worcestershire sauce. Add hot sauce if you’re brave.
Best Dishes to Pair It With
Pork ribs or chicken. Also great as a glaze for smoked sausage.
Craving authentic Carolina Gold? Try Jaco’s Sauce Lekker Gold Mustard BBQ Sauce—a small-batch take on this Southern classic.
Pee Dee Region Tomato-Based Sauce
The Pee Dee area (northeast SC) uses a tomato-heavy sauce, thicker than Lexington’s but less sweet than Memphis styles.
How It Differs From Lexington Dip
More tomato, less vinegar. Think of it as a middle ground between Lexington and Kansas City.
Common Uses
Slathered on pulled pork or as a dipping sauce for brisket.
Lesser-Known Carolina BBQ Sauces
Not every sauce fits the big four. Some spots mix styles:
Alabama White Sauce Influence
Mayo-based Alabama sauce sneaks into northern SC BBQ joints, especially for chicken.
Hybrid Sauces in Border Towns
Near Georgia? You might find peach juice or bourbon added for sweetness.
How to Choose the Right Sauce for Your Meat
BBQ Sauce Pairing Guide
|
Sauce Type
|
Best Meat Pairing
|
Serving Tip
|
|
Eastern Vinegar
|
Whole-hog pork
|
Serve room temp
|
|
Lexington Dip
|
Pork shoulder, chicken
|
Mix into slaw
|
|
Carolina Gold Mustard
|
Pulled pork, smoked sausage
|
Brush on ribs post-grill
|
The South accounts for 55% of U.S. pork consumption (USDA), so don’t shy away from generous saucing!
DIY Carolina BBQ Sauce Recipes
Simple Eastern Vinegar Sauce
1 cup apple cider vinegar
1 tbsp red pepper flakes
1 tsp salt
Mix, let sit overnight.
Sweet Lexington Dip Recipe
1 cup vinegar
½ cup ketchup
2 tbsp brown sugar
1 tsp black pepper
Simmer for 10 minutes.
Why Carolina Sauces Don’t Use Much Sugar
Carolina BBQ focuses on meat, not sweetness. Sugar can burn during smoking, so sauces add flavor after cooking.
The Role of Heat in Carolina Sauces
Pepper flakes or hot sauce add heat, balancing the vinegar’s acidity. Adjust to taste—some like it fiery!
Carolina BBQ Sauce vs. Other US Styles
-
Kansas City: Sweet, molasses-heavy.
-
Texas: Spicy, chili-based.
-
Carolina: Tangy, vinegar-forward.
Where to Buy Authentic Carolina Sauces
Look for brands like Scott’s BBQ Sauce (Eastern NC) or Bessinger’s (SC mustard). Farmers’ markets often sell local batches.
Carolina BBQ Sauce in Pop Culture
From The Avengers (Tony Stark eats Carolina BBQ) to country songs, it’s a Southern icon.
Preserving Tradition in Modern BBQ
New chefs experiment, but old-school pits stay loyal to vinegar, mustard, or tomato. The debate? Part of the fun.
Conclusion
Carolina BBQ sauce isn’t one-size-fits-all. Whether you’re Team Vinegar, Team Mustard, or somewhere in between, there’s a flavor for every palate. Grab a fork, try them all, and pick your side!
FAQs
-
Is Carolina BBQ sauce only for pork?
Mostly, but it works with chicken, turkey, or even veggies.
-
Why is Eastern NC sauce so thin?
It’s meant to soak into meat, not sit on top.
-
Can I make SC mustard sauce less tangy?
Add honey or brown sugar to sweeten it.
-
What’s the best way to store homemade sauce?
In a jar in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.
-
Do any Carolina sauces use mayo?
Rarely—that’s more an Alabama thing, but some SC spots borrow the idea.
Hungry for more? Shop Jaco’s Sauce to taste South Carolina’s iconic mustard gold.
